Search

Abstract vector art

How much should your home down payment be?

By Robin Wetherbee

September 2015

My husband and I were 27 when we bought our house. We had no idea what we were doing. But motivated by our mutual dislike for paying rent for a crappy apartment, we dove in.

With great luck and the recommendation of a friend, we had our real estate agent, Michael, for guidance. He helped us figure out what we could comfortably and conservatively afford, advising us not to strap ourselves with too great of a house payment. Michael helped us think things through with regard to the kind of house we wanted and where we could afford to live. He also helped us determine how much money we would need for a down payment. (Nowadays, we might have tried an online down payment calculator in addition to consulting a trusted professional like Michael.)

Down payment considerations: the line in the sand

Michael laid out what our down payment options were: If we had enough for 20% down, we could finance without mortgage insurance; if we put less down, our lender would require us to get it.

Here are some other considerations Michael gave us.

20% or more down

  • Pro: The larger your down payment, the lower your monthly mortgage payment
  • Pro: Your lender will not require mortgage insurance — that’s one less expense each month
  • Con: It may take you longer to save up your down payment
  • Con: By the time you’ve saved up for a down payment, the home you want to buy may not be on the market or its price may have increased

So, for example, a 20% down payment on a home priced at $150,000 would be $30,000. 

Less than 20% down

  • Pro: Your savings goal will be smaller, so you’ll need less time to reach it
  • Pro: You’ll be able to buy sooner than later
  • Con: The smaller your down payment, the larger your monthly mortgage payment
  • Con: Your lender will require FHA or private mortgage insurance — an additional expense included with your mortgage payment. (If you finance with private mortgage insurance, typically, you can cancel it once you have enough equity in your home.)

So, for example, a 10% down payment on a home priced at $150,000 would be $15,000; a 5% down payment would be $7,500.

Where we landed

It wasn’t long before we found The Little House of Our Dreams with a price tag in our range. We had been saving, but were nowhere near the amount we needed for 20% down. Our worry was that, in the time we’d need to save the difference, somebody else could buy it.

We scraped together a 10% down payment, becoming all too familiar with Kraft macaroni and cheese in the process. And we financed using private mortgage insurance.

After we had been in our home for four years, Michael sent us a letter reminding us that we may be able to cancel our mortgage insurance. So we did — and we reduced our mortgage payment doing so.

Elisa V Rice

Good

mahir

useful

Brandon baker

Really made me feel better about buying a house thanks

Antonio Davis

Definitely helpful !

Rose Bakies

Very helpful.

Tyronne

Great information.

christopher doherty

Great info. Thank you

Jovanny Hernandez

I don’t know to much english, I just want to thank you for helping me . I will work hard to keep my home, thank you again

Tanya Jenkins

I really would like to buy this house that I’ve been living in for the last past three years but I don’t know how to go about buying it

John Hershberger

Thanks for the info

Fran Laycock

Thus is very helpful. Thank you

Fran Laycock

This was very interesting and made a lot of sense.

Talisha Scott Stephen Santiago

This was very helpful.

Lourdes corona

My Realtor finally found the house I wanted

Sabrine Tignor

Helpful

Sandra Croom

Thanks for the info

John carlos medeiros

Helpful

Brenda Rojo

Wow very informative

Susanna Ehrmann

very informative, especially for first-time buyers

Maryann Z Eberly

im ready to buy a house.

Weigh In

Readynest reviews all comments to ensure a respectful dialogue, so your comment may take a day to appear. We do not post inappropriate or abusive comments.

Robin Wetherbee has been writing for MGIC about mortgage insurance and homeownership since 1989. She and her handsome husband reside in Milwaukee’s Bay View neighborhood. They share their freshly empty nest, which she calls her “Miracle on 34th Street” house (if you’ve seen the 1947 movie, you’ll know exactly what she means) with their big old black cat, Max Rayfield Gilhooly.